
M Social Hotel New York Times Square
Best for rooftop Times Square views, Broadway nights, and large group events.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
M Social Hotel New York Times Square is a modern, 4-star Midtown hotel with a large rooftop terrace and a party-forward Theater District location; read this if you want lively Times Square views and easy Broadway access. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a 5-star Upper East Side landmark known for classic luxury and a long-standing social scene; read this if you prefer traditional New York elegance, museums, and Central Park access.
Updated · about 3.7 km apart

Best for rooftop Times Square views, Broadway nights, and large group events.

Best for classic, refined stays near Central Park and the city’s major museums.
When M Social wins: choose M Social if you want a lively Midtown base near Broadway, a large rooftop terrace overlooking Times Square, modern rooms at scale, and flexible event space for groups and parties.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if your priority is traditional five-star service, a smaller, quieter hotel near Central Park and the Met, in-room comforts tied to a luxury brand, and an on-site full-service spa and iconic bar/lounge.
Bottom line: pick M Social for energetic Midtown theater-and-nightlife access and rooftop energy; pick The Carlyle for classic Upper East Side luxury, quieter streets, and proximity to museums and Central Park.
| Category | M Social Hotel New York Times Square | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Modern, lively, rooftop-focused | Classic, refined, Old‑New York society hotel |
| Location | Theater District / Midtown West, steps from Broadway and Times Square | Upper East Side, blocks from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size | 480 rooms across 33 floors | 188 guestrooms |
| Age/style | Contemporary hotel (modern design and large scale) | Art Deco / classic luxury hotel with a long history |
| Pools / beach | No pool | |
| Restaurants & bars | Beast & Butterflies (lobby + 7th-floor rooftop terrace), breakfast/lunch/dinner and cocktails | Two on-site restaurants/coffee shop and Bemelman's Bar/lounge; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa / wellness | No spa; 24-hour fitness center (8th floor) | Full-service spa and fitness facilities |
| Known for | Wraparound 7th-floor terrace with Times Square views and large event terrace | Historic Upper East Side address, Bemelman's Bar, and Rosewood-brand service |
| Family policy | Family-friendly; children stay free (restrictions apply); minimum check-in age 18 | All ages welcome (not adults-only); minimum check-in age not published here |
| Meeting & events | Large terrace event space (7,500 sq ft), multiple boardrooms, scalable event capacities | Fewer meeting rooms (1 listed), boutique event options |
M Social sits in Midtown’s Theater District, a few blocks from Broadway and Times Square.
Choose M Social for direct access to Broadway, Times Square energy, and Midtown attractions.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street near Madison Avenue, inside the Upper East Side museum and Central Park corridor.
Choose The Carlyle to be close to museums, Central Park, and a calmer Upper East Side setting.
M Social offers 480 rooms across 33 floors with room types targeted to theater and family travelers.
M Social suits travelers who want modern, efficient rooms with options for families and views of Midtown.
The Carlyle offers a smaller collection of traditionally styled rooms and many named suites.
The Carlyle is for travelers who want classic, roomy accommodations with luxury touches and suite options.
M Social’s food-and-drink life centers on Beast & Butterflies and the rooftop terrace overlooking Times Square.
Pick M Social for rooftop cocktails and a more casual, social dining vibe with direct views of Midtown lights.
The Carlyle’s dining scene is more traditional, anchored by its bar/lounge and two restaurants.
Choose The Carlyle for classic hotel dining and an iconic bar experience rather than rooftop nightlife.
M Social’s standout feature is the 7,500 sq ft M Social Terrace above Times Square plus a wraparound 7th-floor terrace.
M Social is geared to events that want a skyline/Times Square backdrop and larger capacities.
The Carlyle’s signature is its Rosewood-level service, quieter event offerings, and storied social spaces like Bemelman's Bar.
The Carlyle is suited to travelers who prefer curated, service-driven experiences and intimate private events.
M Social focuses on fitness access and rooftop nightlife rather than spa treatments.
M Social fits guests who prioritize a fitness facility and rooftop nightlife over spa services.
The Carlyle includes a full-service spa and traditional hotel nightlife in its bar/lounge.
The Carlyle is better when you want on-site spa treatments and a quieter, classic evening setting.

M Social — steps from Broadway theaters and a short walk to Times Square with a rooftop terrace for evening views.

The Carlyle — traditional five-star service with easy walking access to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

M Social — large, flexible rooftop terrace and modular event spaces that scale from boardrooms to parties for hundreds.

The Carlyle — full-service spa, smaller guest count, and a more subdued Upper East Side setting.
M Social — it's in the Theater District, within a few minutes' walk of many Broadway theaters and Times Square.
The Carlyle — it’s a short walk from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art and suits quieter, museum-focused itineraries.
No — M Social does not have a pool and there is no pool listed for The Carlyle in the supplier details.
Yes — both properties welcome guests of all ages; M Social explicitly offers kids-stay-free perks and a kids' menu. The Carlyle is not adults-only.
The Carlyle has a full-service spa; M Social does not have a spa and focuses on a 24-hour fitness center instead.
Explore how M Social Hotel New York Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·